Compare Medical Alert Systems

Comparing medical alert systems can be difficult, but our compare tool makes it easy! Simply use the drop down arrows Red Drop Down Arrow below to find the life alert cost and more. Compare any two medical alert systems like, Life Alert vs Medical Alert, with the currently featured system.

Make Your Selections Below To Compare Systems Side-By-Side

DISCLOSURE: We may receive a referral fee when you contact a medical alert company or use a coupon code on this site. Thanks to your support, we can maintain this website & offer you special discounts, at no cost to you.



Medical Guardian Logo

Medical Guardian Classic Guardian Pendant Button Pressed

LifeStation logo

LifeStation In-Home Pendant

LifeFone Medical Alert Logo

LifeFone Pendant and Console

Medical Guardian
Cost for EquipmentFree equipment (excluding the MGMove & Mini Guardian) and no set-up or activation or charges. Shipping is $12.50 but waived with annual payment plans.Free equipment and free shipping if you choose quarterly or annual payments. Simple 5-minute self-installation. Keep in mind a few options will have an activation fee which is outlined below.Free equipment with no activation or shipping charges
Cost Per MonthCost per month starts at $29.95 and up.Plans start as low as $32.95 per monthThe starting costs for LifeFone's monthly services are $24.95 per month when paid annually.
Advance Payment DiscountsYesNoYes
Monitoring Agreement TermNo contracts. Can cancel anytime. If you cancel mid-month, you will be refunded the amount you pre-paid.Month-to-month. Can cancel anytime with 30 day advance notice. LifeStation also offers a 30-day money back guarantee for any system and payment plan.Cancel at any time and receive refund of any unused, prepaid service with the return of the equipment.
Repairs or Replacement ChargesNone, replacements shipped free for defective equipment and battery replacements. Optional $6.99/month Protection Plan for damaged or lost equipment that could cost up to $350.00 to replace without it.None, replacements shipped. Select & Supreme packages come with their Protection Plan which covers damaged or lost equipment. Without the plan, it's about $34.95 for a new button and about $300 for a new base station. Or you can purchase the protection plan separately for $5.00 per month.None, replacements shipped free, there is a $39.95 charge is you lose the standard button and a $90 charge for a lost fall detection button. You can purchase a LifeFone protection plan for $5.00 a month.
Cancellation Policy & Discounts
Medical Guardian
Cancel at Any TimeYesYes. LifeStation also offers a 30-day money back guarantee for any system and payment plan. On systems returned after the 30-day money back guarantee period - The monthly charge may be refunded on systems returned within 7 days of the last monthly charge date. Customers who pay quarterly or annually do NOT receive refunds for prepaid services.Yes. This company also refunds unused, prepaid amounts, but you pay to ship the equipment back.
Senior DiscountNoAARP discount of $2.00/month & veterans receive the discounted annual rate even when paying monthly. Can only use one discount at a time.No
Other DiscountsNoNone

Refer a friend and receive one month free for each referral and the person you refer will also receive one free month.

Medical Guardian
Approximate Button Range in Typical HomeThe Classic Guardian, Home Guardian 2.0, and Family Guardian systems have a 1,400 ft. range.Alert pendant has up to a 650 ft. radiusUp to 1,400 ft for the In-Home system to the base unit. 
Watch/Button Battery LifeBattery will last approximately 3-5 years. Has low battery indicator.Lithium battery will last up to 4 years with normal operation. Sends signal when low. The Mobile GPS system can go 5 days without needing a charge.Battery will last approximately 2-5 years. LifeFone will contact you when the battery is low for a free replacement. The battery life with fall detection button is approximately 5 days.
What Happens if I Lose PowerApproximately 32 hours of backup batteryAt Home system has battery backupApproximately 32 hours of battery backup.
Is the Watch/Button WaterproofYesYesYes
How Can The Button Be WornNeck and wrist options. Can choose both when ordering but a 2nd button will cost $2.99/month.Neck or wrist. Choose when ordering.Neck, wrist or wall-mounted options. Must choose when ordering.
UL Certified EquipmentYesYesYes
Does The System Automatically Test Itself To The Monitoring CenterMonthlyWeeklyYes - Monthly
24 Hour Technical & Customer SupportCustomer Support is available 9:00 AM - 8:00 PM EST (Monday - Friday) and 9:00AM to 5:00PM EST on Saturday. The monitoring center is always available for medical alert support 24 hours per day, 7 days per week.YesLifeFone’s monitoring centers are open 24/7. Their customer service is available to answer general questions from 8am - 10pm ET, 7 days a week.
Monitoring Station
Medical Guardian
TMA Five Diamond Certified Monitoring CenterYes, but not company owned.Yes. LifeStation operates their own TMA Five Diamond UL-Listed monitoring centers located in Houston, TX and Union, NJ. These monitoring centers are geographically separated and networked to provide redundancy in the event of a failure or natural disaster.Yes
Typical Response Time When Button PressedApproximately 30-45 secondsResponse time is approximately 20 seconds.Per the company, the average is 15 seconds. 
Other Options & Information
Medical Guardian
How Fast Does System ShipShips same day if received and processed by 3:00 PM ESTOrders Received by 3:00PM EST are Shipped FREE the Same DaySame day if order received by 3:00 PM EST. Typical 3-5 day delivery. Expedited shipping options are available for an additional charge.
Do You Need Separate Systems For Mom & DadNo, but an additional button is $2.99/month.No. $3.95/month for an additional buttonNo, spouses are covered free. Just pay for an extra help button at $39.95.
Optional Advanced Features
Medical Guardian
Activity or Inactivity MonitoringNoNoYes, they call it Activity Assurance ($6.00/month).
Senior Fall DetectionYes. With all systems except the MGMove.YesYes. Cost varies from $5-10 per month, depending on the system you add it to.
Cellular or No Phone LineYes. Home Guardian 2.0, Mobile Guardian 2.0, MGMove, and Mini GuardianYesYes, with all systems except the At-Home Landline system
Smoke or Carbon Monoxide ProtectionNoNoNo
GPS Medical Alert Tracking SystemYes. Mobile Guardian 2.0, MGMove Smartwatch, and Mini GuardianYesYes, with At-Home & On-the-Go, the At-Home & On-the-Go Voice in Pendant systems and VIPx.
Star Rating




Special Offers
Medical Guardian
Special Offers For Our Visitors

DISCLOSURE: We may receive referral fees from this company for purchases or inquiries made by you. Thanks to your support, we can maintain the website & offer you special discounts, at no cost to you.


  • Get a FREE Month, FREE Ground Shipping, FREE Month of Service, and FREE Lockbox for new customers purchasing annual subscriptions on select plans & equipment.
Medical Guardian 1-800-988-8105



DISCLOSURE: We may receive referral fees from this company for purchases or inquiries made by you. Thanks to your support, we can maintain the website & offer you special discounts, at no cost to you.

  • 30-Day Money Back Guarantee!
  • Industry Leading Response Time
  • Free Shipping
  • New Exclusive Feature - “Find My Loved One” only at LifeStation

LifeStation 1-877-354-3041



DISCLOSURE: We may receive referral fees from this company for purchases or inquiries made by you. Thanks to your support, we can maintain the website & offer you special discounts, at no cost to you.

Get 1 Free Month + Free Shipping & Activation PLUS a Price Lock Guarantee!

  • 30-day Money Back Guarantee
  • Lifetime Subscriber Price & Equipment Guarantee
  • Spouses Protected Free
  • Cancel At Any Time & Prepaid Unused Services Are Fully Refunded
LifeFone 1-844-201-3982



Medical Alert Advice was created to simplify your online shopping search for the latest medical alert devices. We created this handy cost comparison guide to help your decision-making process when researching medical alert systems. Think of our site as your personal alert system consultant! If you are looking for yourself or a family member, our handy medical alert guides can help create a medical alert expert out of anyone! We cover the basics including reviewing many of the features you will be looking for when researching emergency response systems, such as monthly fee information, equipment pricing, pendant options, medical and/or medication monitoring and automatic fall detection. This comparison chart has it. You are able to see if the medical alert company you are interested in has location GPS tracking, GPS mobile alert devices, smartphone apps and a backup battery in case of a power outage.

We also break down the latest medical alert information technology such as voice-in-pendant and the latest activity monitoring options. Having a handsfree medical alert pendant these days, as opposed to being tied to a base unit, can be like using a wearable computer. It can detect all types of movement such as fitness tracking and detecting falls. Some medical alert systems come with fall detection automatically built in. If your device doesn’t come automated with fall detection, it most likely is available as an add-on option. Seniors who are susceptible to falls or have foot problems, may want to utilize automatic fall detection as an add-on option.

In some cases, you might not need a medical alert pendant at all! Some of the companies we review have caregiving and tracking apps for your mobile phone and some have smartwatch devices that blend seamlessly into your everyday lifestyle. You loved one can assess risk management from across the country with the help of these apps.

Another feature to look out for is a company that also provides whole house surveillance as add on to their medical alert system offerings. Having access to the additional security and protection may help bring your family peace and calmness if they live far away.

Our reviews stand out for our detailed price evaluation of each company’s offerings. We discuss payment discounts, contracts and what is industry standard. We even break down the packing and labeling time to process orders and shipping costs. We call in to each customer service center to get a feel of the full human to human experience. We know that signing up for a medical alert monitoring service can be a long-term financial transaction and we want to educate people on the exact amount of money they will need to pay for these systems and services.

Many questions were researched to compile this comparison and create our life alert reviews. The information we gather, may have been obtained from the company's website, telephone conversations with sales representatives, on-line chats, product brochures, and other website sources. If the information received during this research conflicted, we listed the most frequent answer. Be sure to verify that the service you choose is right for you and not to rely solely on the information provided on this website or others. Keep in mind that most medical alert companies are based in the United States and their services work only in the U.S., although some may also serve Canada. If you live outside the country, you may want to find another solution.

As people enter old age, a medical alert system can help them age in place longer. We know you can trust our expert medical alert comparisons as they are written with the consumer’s best interest in mind. We wish you luck in learning which medical emergency system is right for you or your aging loved one and remember that help is only a telephone call away!

Recommended for you...
Find out Philips Lifeline cost information and all other features in our detailed review.

*LifeStation logo is a registered trademark of LifeStation, Inc., Medical Guardian logo is a registered trademark of Medical Guardian, LLC, Philips Lifeline logo is a registered trademark of Philips N.V.