Automatic Fall Detection For Seniors

Most traditional medical alert monitoring systems rely on a pendant or button that your loved one must press in order to call for help. These systems are highly effective and save lives every day.

Some seniors, though, are at a higher risk of falling than others. There is the possibility that when your loved one falls, they may be unable to press their medical alert button to call for help. This is where Automatic Fall Detection comes in.

Automatic fall detection technology is a newcomer to the medical alert monitoring industry and it’s not without some controversy, since they can’t detect 100% of all falls. Read our most frequently asked questions in regards to medical alert devices with fall detection to learn more.

 

Automatic Fall Detection

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

 

1. What is Automatic Fall Detection and how does it work?

Automatic fall detection, or Automated Fall Detection, is typically built into the medical alert pendant that may also be worn on your waist, depending on your system. They can be worn while relaxing on the couch or even sleeping.

Medical Guardian FallAlert Pendant MobileHelp Fall Button

These systems feature sensors (multiple accelerometers and processors) that can detect between normal activity, and an actual fall. By continuously measuring the speed of movements in all directions, the fall detector can compare what it senses to what it considers an actual fall.

You and your kids probably use accelerometers everyday without even knowing it. If you have an iPhone (or other smartphone), you’ll notice that your screen changes when you turn your phone sideways. Or when your child uses a Wii gaming system remote control to swing a bat or throw a ball in a game, accelerometers are involved in tracking their movement and displaying their results in the game.

Since fall detectors can sense what position they are in, how fast they are moving, and how they are moving (smoothly or abruptly) 80% of users experience no false fall detections per month while 90% of users experience one or fewer false detections per month. This is according to a Medical Guardian technical bulletin.

2. How does Automatic Fall Detection benefit seniors?

The benefits of automatic fall detection to seniors can be great. Considering that one-third of adults over 65 will fall each year, fall related injuries are not uncommon. Also, if you or your loved one has diabetes or another condition that increases your risk of falling, this feature might provide you with additional piece of mind.

If your loved one sustains an injury or becomes unconscious from a fall and they are alone, their chance of getting help fast is increased significantly by automatic fall detection technology. Please see our article Falls Are The Leading Cause Of Injury Deaths Among Older Adults on the dangers of falls to seniors.

3. Does my loved one really need Automatic Fall Detection?

    • Have you or another family member ever witnessed your loved one fall?
    • Do they live alone, or is their spouse still living?
    • Are they beginning to “shuffle” their feet rather than take complete steps?
    • Are there trip hazards around the home like throw rugs, areas where the floor is uneven, or rooms that have different floor types like carpet, ceramic tile, vinyl, or hardwood floors? Daughter with Mom
    • Is there different floor types in each room which create a “threshold” trip hazard?
    • Do they have to use stairs to get around in their home?
    • Does your loved one need to step into a bathtub to use the shower?
    • Do your aging parents think they can still do just about anything on their own, and you have worries every time you see them doing it?
    • Does your elderly loved one have a medical condition such as diabetes that is prone to fainting spells?

Answering these questions may help you decide whether you or your loved one should seriously consider a system with automatic fall detection features.

4. What features should I look for in an Automatic Fall Detection medical alert system?

Besides the features that every traditional medical alert system should provide (see What Are The Most Important Features of a Medical Alert System? ) these systems may offer other advanced features that you may find useful.

First, you need to understand how the technology actually works and what its limitations are. You should consider the following:

    • Is the fall detection device truly automatic? If you are unable to push your button for help, the automatic fall detection technology will do it for you.
    • Is the detection device waterproof? Falls can occur in the bath or shower so this is an important feature.
    • How reliable is the technology? Once you receive your system, be sure to test its functionality for your loved one (with them present) so you are all aware how the system and service will operate.
    • Is the device comfortable to wear or will it get in the way during everyday activities?
    • How easy to use is the system? You don’t want anything that is complicated. If the system is truly automatic, then ease-of use-should not be a real issue. You would also need to make sure your device is easily accessible.
    • Can you still simply press a button if you need help, or does the system only detect falls? The system should always provide a button to call for help. Many times the button can also be used to cancel the fall detection if you are OK or the system made a false detection.
    • Does the system tell you if the battery is low in the pendant and whether it needs to be changed or charged?
    • As with all medical alert systems, does the fall detection system require a traditional telephone line to operate or can it reliably work with cellular or VoIP telephone services, and does it have that technology built-in?

5. What are the limitations of Automatic Fall Detection?

Given that Automatic Fall Detection is relatively new technology, there is some room for improvement. One possible inconvenience could be false alarms. These can occur if there is a sudden movement and then the user perhaps lays down or sits in a chair without any further movement. This could warrant unwanted paramedics to show up at your door, but advances in this technology appear to have greatly reduced false detections.

Something else to consider is accuracy. Movements such as sliding might not be detected. It is important to note that Automatic Fall Detection is not 100% accurate.

6. How to use a Fall Detection System

Today’s fall detection technology can sense a fall of less than two feet. This means that even if you fall off your sofa onto the floor, the sensor can call for help.It’s important to understand that it may take several seconds for the system to decide whether it has detected an actual fall, but this will help limit false alarms.

With the unit shown below, once a fall has been detected, the base station will announce, Fall Detected.Press and Hold Button to Cancel. If you or your loved one actually needs help and do not cancel the alarm, the unit will then say, Fall Medical Guardian FallAlert SystemDetected.Contacting Emergency Response Center. Please Stand by for Operator. Once the system connects to an operator, they will ask if you or you loved one are okay and need help.

If they are able to speak to the operator they can tell them the type of help they need. If you or your loved one is unconscious or unable to speak, the operator will automatically send emergency support services to the home.

7. Tips for using your system

    • It’s best to wear the button on the outside of your clothes. The unit will do a better and more accurate job if it’s not obstructed by clothing.
    • Depending on your system, you should be able to manually cancel the automatic fall detection alert by pressing and holding the pendant emergency button or the reset button on the base station for a certain amount of time, as described by your service provider. Please be sure to understand how to do this.
    • If a fall alarm or an alarm you manually initiate with the pendant or base station button is not canceled, the operator will talk to you through the base station unit. If the operator cannot hear you or you do not respond, emergency help will be sent automatically.

8. Is Automatic Fall Detection worth the extra cost?

After carefully considering the needs of your loved one, their current living environment, and how much time you are available to be with them, one other major factor to consider is cost. With the monthly costs nearly twice that of a traditional medical alert monitoring system, the cost alone may be the deciding factor. Is the extra costs worth it? Only you can make that decision. Keep in mind, these systems can not detect 100% of all falls.

9. What companies offer Automatic Fall Detection systems and how do they compare?

Automatic fall detection has been around for a short-time compared to traditional medical alert monitoring systems. Due to the complexity of the systems, there are less companies that have been able to introduce reliable fall detection systems.

Below are some companies that offer Automatic Fall Detection medical alert systems. Take a look and see how they compare.

 

Medical Guardian Logo Philips Lifeline Logo MobileHelp
Medical Guardian FallAlert Button Philips Lifeline Autoalert Pendant MobileHelp Fall Button
Product Medical Guardian FallAlert Philips Lifeline AutoAlert MobileHelp Fall Button
Pricing Medical Guardian FallAlert Philips Lifeline AutoAlert MobileHelp® Fall Button
Installation / Equipment FREE Activation and NO Equipment Fees, FREE Shipping No Activation or Set-up fees. No Activation or Set-up fees.
Base Monthly Charges $44.95 / Month ($41.20/Month if Paid Annually) $44.95/Month $44.95/Month
Monitoring Agreement
Cancellation Policy
Cancel at any time, and receive a full refund for all unused months of service Cancel Anytime with 30 Days Notice No Contract & 30-Day Trial
Repairs or Replacement Charges No charge for normal wear and tear of the system, all replacements shipped at no cost to user. None For Normal Wear, Replacements Shipped None For Normal Wear, Replacements Shipped
Equipment Medical Guardian FallAlert Philips Lifeline AutoAlert MobileHelp® Fall Button
How Can The Button Be Worn As a Pendant or on the Hip Pendant Pendant
UL Certified Equipment Yes Yes Yes
Telephone Line Required? No. Uses Cellular Service. All Charges are Included in Your Monthly Fee. Both Landline & Cellular Options Are Available No. Uses Cellular Service
Special Offers Medical Guardian FallAlert Philips Lifeline AutoAlert MobileHelp® Fall Button
Special Offers For Our Visitors Medical Guardian 1-800-988-8105

1-800-988-8105
None at this time None at this time